Our office will be closed Thursday and Friday, November 26th and 27th for the Thanksgiving holiday. We will reopen at regular business hours on Monday, November 30th.
Validation of Two Self-Reported Sleep Duration Measures Against Objective Estimates of Sleep Duration in a Large UK Adolescent Cohort
- Presented on June 3, 2013
Introduction Self-reported sleep duration is widely used but may not provide accurate information. Correlations between objective estimates of sleep and self-reported data only demonstrate if a relationship is present but do not determine if the two measures agree. We sought to determine levels of agreement between two self-reported average weekday sleep duration measures and one objective estimate(actigraphy) of average weekday sleep duration.
Methods Students (n=642), aged 11-13 years, were recruited from eight secondary schools in the Midlands region of the UK. The Schools Sleep Habits Survey was administered to obtain self-reported weekday sleep duration (WSD). Immediately after completion, students wore wrist actigraphy (GT3X+) for 7 consecutive days whilst also completing a 7-day diary.
Results Mean weekday sleep duration+/-SD (minutes) according to self-report, sleep diary and actigraphy were 534+/-76, 527+/-44, and 448+/-47, respectively. A positive correlation was observed between self-reported WSD and actigraphy measured average WSD r=0.19, p=0.01. Average sleep diary WSD was positively correlated with average actigraphy WSD r=0.31, p<0.001. Bland-Altman plots showed a mean of 82.9 and a region of agreement between self-reported average WSD and mean actigraphy WSD of 219.3 to -53.5 with nine data points falling outside of the upper and lower bound limits. A further Bland-Altman plot revealed a mean of 76.2 and a region of agreement between average sleep diary WSD and average actigraphy-measured WSD of 183.6 to -31.2 with >95% of the data falling within the levels of agreement.
Conclusion Self-reported average WSD, as measured through sleep diaries and survey data, were significantly correlated with objectively estimated WSD in our large adolescent cohort. Both self-reported measures of average weekday sleep duration in adolescents agreed with objectively determined average WSD data with 95% of the data falling within the levels of agreement when graphically plotted. Self-reported WSD may be confidently used as a cost-efficient method in future studies.
Support: Action Medical Research provided study funding.