Our office will remain closed through Friday, September 18th as we continue to assess the damages caused by Hurricane Sally. ActiGraph team members are working remotely, however shipping delays should be expected at this time. We expect to resume regular business hours on Monday, September 21st. If you need immediate assistance, please contact us by email at email@example.com and we will respond as quickly as possible. Thank you for your continued support.
Physical Activity Change in an RCT: Comparison of Measurement Methods
- Published on May 7, 2019
We aimed to quantify the agreement between self-report, standard cut-point accelerometer, and machine learning accelerometer estimates of physical activity (PA), and examine how agreement changes over time among older adults in an intervention setting.
Data were from a randomized weight loss trial that encouraged increased PA among 333 postmenopausal breast cancer survivors. PA was estimated using accelerometry and a validated questionnaire at baseline and 6-months. Accelerometer data were processed using standard cut-points and a validated machine learning algorithm. Agreement of PA at each time-point and change was assessed using mixed effects regression models and concordance correlation.
At baseline, self-report and machine learning provided similar PA estimates (mean difference = 11.5 min/day) unlike self-report and standard cut-points (mean difference = 36.3 min/ day). Cut-point and machine learning methods assessed PA change over time more similarly than other comparisons. Specifically, the mean difference of PA change for the cut-point versus machine learning methods was 5.1 min/day for intervention group and 2.9 in controls, whereas it was ⩾ 24.7 min/day for other comparisons.
Intervention researchers are facing the issue of self-report measures introducing bias and accelerometer cut-points being insensitive. Machine learning approaches may bridge this gap.
- Nelson, Sandahl H.
- Natarajan, Loki
- Patterson, Ruth E.
- Hartman, Sheri J.
- Thompson, Caroline A.
- Godbole, Suneeta V.
- Johnson, Eileen
- Marinac, Catherine R.
- Kerr, Jacqueline
American Journal of Health Behavior